Skip to main content

Tim Anderson and the suspension that Major League Baseball can't enforce


Tim Anderson plays shortstop for the Chicago White Sox and he's off to a fantastic start to the season.  Not only did he welcome his second daughter to the world in April, but statistically, he is off to the hottest start of his career and one of the hottest starts in the league.  He's hitting .422 for the year, with 4 home runs, and 7 stolen bases.  The batting average puts him at first in the American League.  Not too shabby.  



Anderson has also attracted some attention to himself for the newfound energy he has brought the game.  Anderson is one of the more energetic players I've seen lately and he's at the forefront of a new trend we're saying: bat flips and emotion are the new "in" thing.  His most recent bat flip was more of a throw than anything else.  We saw Bryce Harper excessively flip a bat when he hit a home run against his former team.  We've even seen pitchers start to get involved in the fun with their own version of a bat flip (the insiders call this "pimping" a strikeout).   The only problem with all of this is that it feels awfully similar to America in 2019 -- in the midst of a cultural clash.  The opposition to this newfound emotion is just as strong.  They insist that players "act like they've been there" and just carry on with their day as normal.  

 This cultural clash roared to the surface following one of Tim Anderson's at bats -- immediately following the "bat flip" event, Anderson was hit by a pitch and the benches cleared.  In the process, Anderson yelled a racial epithet towards the pitcher (the n-word).  It was this event -- and not anything else -- that yielded Anderson a 1-game suspension.  And it's this that I have a problem with: an unenforceable suspension.

 Note:  Yes, I realize that the suspension was enforced and Anderson took the suspension without appeal.  That's not my issue.

My issue is with something bigger.  The league has thrown down a suspension for something it can't enforce.  Sure, there have been a few suspensions over time regarding language.  It has happened.  But how strictly is the league enforcing those boundaries?  Has the league even bothered to establish a boundary in the first place?  It's not clear to me.  Is the league telling us that this is the first time this particular racial epithet was used ever?  

I personally disagree with using that particular word.  But as a white person (OK, half-Cuban), I am entitled to no opinion over that word.  And that's part of the reason I don't like the way that this suspension feels.  We haven't had a real conversation about race in baseball and yet we're levying a suspension based on a racial word.   Where is the standard exactly?  Where are the boundaries?  As I sit here typing, I recognize that this ball of yarn is pretty hard to unwind.  As Adam Jones and Marcus Stroman explained in their defense of Tim Anderson, the word in question here is fully embedded culturally as slang.  I'm not suggesting that's a problem for Major League Baseball, but it is something that needs to be discussed and addressed globally.  Are white players held to the same standards for any similarly-damaging words?  If not, why not?  The idea of a double-standard is particularly damaging for a league that is desperate for new talent and new fans.  

 The emotion-charged wave has been positive for baseball this year.  The decorum is important, but so is the emotion.  There is a place for both and maybe we'll tackle that topic at a later day.  But for now, we should be more concerned that the league has set itself up for failure at a critical juncture.


Popular posts from this blog

The Power of Allowing Yourself to Fail

I don't know about you, but I really hate to fail.  I am willing to do almost anything to avoid failing.  I hate it.  I am willing to do things I otherwise wouldn't want to do, only if it means I can avoid failing at something.   It's not so much about not getting what I want, however.  I think, in isolation, I can grapple with that outcome and figure out what to do next. The thing we seem to be afraid of is failing in front of others.  We worry about what they'll think of us and our reputation.  Our reputation is our brand, after all. But maybe instead of thinking about this in terms of a binary "pass, fail" set of options, what if the reputation is a set of options surrounding what you do about failure.  And maybe you were putting entirely too much pressure on yourself to achieve one outcome over another.   And so that  is our struggle, our call to action.  Fail - fail to allow yourself to grow.  Fail - fail out of ...
Read more

When you create something bigger, your failures are given context

The first chunk of my life was dictated for me.  I went to school and I was told what to do in school.  I got a job and I was told what to do at that job.  I went to college and I was told what to do in college.  I found a better job and I was told to do in that job.   My success in those different contexts was some milestone, goal, or achievement that was given to me by those different contexts.  I didn't have to think about what the goal was - it was merely given to me.  In some sense, that's great - I appreciate that someone was training me. But the problem is that no one told me that I was merely being trained.  Without necessary communication and context, I kept drifting through the days thinking another goal or milestone would magically appear. Well, it didn't.  And it took me a few years to figure this out - more than I'd like.   What did I learn in the process? That you must set those goals for yourself - even if those ...
Read more

The happenstance of failure - there is a rhyme and reason to the universe

Diagnosing the intersection of time and failure -  Failure comes in many forms. It can be the result of poor choices, lack of effort, or simply being in the wrong place at the wrong time. It can be a small setback, like a missed deadline, or a major catastrophe, like a failed business venture. Regardless of its scale, failure often carries a heavy emotional burden, bringing with it feelings of disappointment, regret, and even shame.    However, failure is not an end point. It is an opportunity for growth and learning. When we examine our failures with honesty and self-reflection, we can identify our mistakes, understand our weaknesses, and develop strategies for improvement. In this way, failure can be a catalyst for personal transformation, pushing us to become more resilient, resourceful, and ultimately, more successful.    What even is happenstance? - Happenstance, also known as serendipity or chance, is the occurrence of events by accident rather than design...
Read more